- News & Publications
- Magistrate Recommends Granting Carter Ledyard’s Motion to Dismiss Federal Lawsuit Claiming Ownership of Iconic Artwork On the Basis of the “Probate Exception”
Magistrate Recommends Granting Carter Ledyard’s Motion to Dismiss Federal Lawsuit Claiming Ownership of Iconic Artwork On the Basis of the “Probate Exception”
In a 33-page report and recommendation issued on August 24, 2018, Magistrate Judge Barbara Moses determined that the iconic artwork “The Mechanism of Meaning” by Shusaku Arakawa, and the intellectual property in that artwork, is under the legal control of the executors of the Estate of Madeline Gins and within the “custody” of the New York probate court, and therefore any dispute over ownership must be litigated in the New York Surrogate’s Court. Carter Ledyard & Milburn LLP sought dismissal of a federal lawsuit claiming ownership of the work and associated intellectual property rights based on the “probate exception” to federal jurisdiction and failure to allege registration of copyright, among other grounds. U.S. District Judge Alison J. Nathan will decide whether to accept Judge Moses’s recommendation and dismiss the federal case. Carter Ledyard attorneys Gary D. Sesser, Judith Wallace, Melissa Erwin and Madelyn White represented the Estate of Madeline Gins, its executors, and the Reversible Destiny Foundation in seeking dismissal of the lawsuit.
The decision is available here.
Approaching the third anniversary of the Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 (DTSA), Jeff Boxer, Jack Griem, Alex Malyshev, and Dylan Ruffi reflect on the recent trends in DTSA litigation.
Client Advisory: Jeff Boxer and Alex Malyshev discuss the Supreme Court's recent unanimous decision in Henry Schein, Inc. v. Archer & White Sales, Inc., and what it means for arbitration.
Alison Powers Herman was promoted from Counsel to Partner, and Mary Winchurch Brown from Associate to Counsel.
The OTC Markets Group provides price and liquidity information for roughly 10,000 over-the-counter securities.
The 1st Department Appellate Division upheld a Supreme Court decision to ban single-use Styrofoam containers in food service establishments in New York City.
Steve participated in the Annual Meeting of the American College of Environmental Lawyers in Jackson Hole, Wyoming to review environmental law developments.
A London-based co-living developer closed on the purchase of a $55 million dollar development site in Bushwick, Brooklyn. Land Use counsel was provided by Paul Proulx.
Judge Alison J. Nathan adopted a report that determined that the iconic artwork, "The Mechanism of Meaning" by Shusaku Arakawa, and associated intellectual property rights, must be litigated in the New York Surrogate’s…
Designed to showcase those exhibiting excellence in the practice of law, Super Lawyers® named forty Carter Ledyard attorneys to this year's list.
Fifteen attorneys across ten practice areas were named by Best Lawyers in their annual The Best Lawyers in America® rankings.
Jeff Boxer spoke with the New York Law Journal about the quality of services provided by a mid-sized law firm like Carter Ledyard.
Ms. Wallace has been a partner at CLM since 2017 and practices Art Law, Environmental Law and Litigation.
Carter Ledyard filed an action in Manhattan's Federal District Court against Pinduoduo, Inc., a multi-billion dollar Chinese-language social e-commerce app.
Our 2017 Year in Review highlights the cutting-edge work of our clients, both foreign and domestic, and some of the ways we helped them succeed.